I’ve never been a die-hard American Idol fan. I’ve always thought that the contestants who did really well on Idol were usually Star Search material, or beauty pageant intermission-special. Kelly Clarkson started off in that manner after she won the first season, but eventually found her own zone and developed a marketable career. Who the hell knows if Ruben Studdard is even alive? Fantasia Barrino has been flitting in and out of the spotlight, and Katherine McPhee is apparently doing movies now. Carrie Underwood seems to be the most successful of the bunch – while doing touring, recording new albums, getting inducted into the Grand Ole Opry and doing commercials, ads and winning awards, she seems the be the only American Idol who has had real all-around success. I never liked her, though. I rooted for Bo Bice when their season was on. As for Jordin Sparks, I don’t care for her at all, and the same goes for David Cook, although I was shocked when he won last year, considering how Simon Cowell practically crowned David Archuleta the winner the night before the results were revealed.
So in a nutshell, although I am not a diehard Idol fan, I do know the Idols, and I’m familiar with how the show is run. Lately, I’ve been growing impressed with the show, because I’ve noticed that this show has really made some major breakthroughs, ratings-wise, drama-wise, talent-wise and society-wise. Let me elaborate. Ratings-wise, American Idol is a monster. If you’re a struggling new show trying to find a niche audience, you don’t wanna go up against something like American Idol. Lost producers winced when they found out that their move to the Wednesday slot at 9pm would pitt their show against AI. With the growing popularity of reality TV because of shows like The Bachelor, Real World and The Hills (although in that aspect let’s call it “reality” TV), the success of American Idol is not unfounded. But despite being sucessful in the ratings department, a show that has been going on for 8 seasons now needs a revamping, and they have revamped the show, for good and bad.
For one, there is the addition of a new judge: singer/songwriter/producer Kara DioGuardi. I personally think she’s a better judge than Paula Abdul, only because she actually makes sense when she opens her mouth, but for some reason she has rubbed American Idol fans the wrong way. All over the internet are pronouncements of disdain over the addition of her to the show. People felt it was unnecessary, but perhaps they fail to understand that maybe this was a preemptive move in the event Simon Cowell would eventually leave the hit show. There have been rumors swirling around that Cowell simply found it too difficult to do two shows during the same week (American Idol and Britain’s Got Talent) and was going to have to choose one of the two to continue on. Since his contract with American Idol is up after this season (8), he is free to do whatever he wants, so he could very well choose to stick with BGT.
Another addition to the show was the Judges Save – meant to be used to redeem a contestant who the judges feel didn’t receive the right number of votes in order to be safe. Because of what we like to call the “Chris Daughty Effect”, which is when somene who appears to be a frontrunner in the competition goes home because their fans got cocky and didn’t bother to call or text to keep their favorite safe. I have to say that I like this idea, only because you have to admit that America fucked up pretty badly with Chris Daughtry, so might as well incorporate it so that no one who’s worth anything is sent home by mistake.
Adam Lambert, who most assumed was going to be a shoo-in for the finale, landed in the bottom on Wednesday night.
This year’s contestants are the most diverse and original that I’ve ever seen on the show. We are down to the final four, and all four contestants bring something different to the table. You have the clear frontrunner (although after last Wednesday’s shocking results show, we’re not so sure anymore) Adam Lambert, who brings his own brand of glam rock/theater chic into the fray; Allison Iraheta, the youngest of the bunch at 17 and who has a very unique voice and a nice edge to her performances; Danny Gokey, who has a compelling story and a soulful, raspy voice and a good range; and Kris Allen, a laid-back, singer-songwriter type who is rarely ever seen without an instrument of choice on stage, may it be a guitar or a keyboard.
All of the contestants are stylistically different, with Kris and Adam on opposite sides of the spectrum. I am betting that when it comes down to the wire, it will be an Adam-Kris finale, which I personally am very excited to see. I think that Adam and Kris balance each other out; one puts on a good show and is crazy, exciting and a great performer, while the other is heartfelt, melodic, genuine and easy to listen to. Either one could nab the top spot, in my opinion, although I personally prefer Kris Allen to win the title.
I think that Adam Lambert is exciting to watch and he definitely gives you a performance to remember, but it’s mostly not because of his singing, but rather, his theatrics. Lambert has a background in theater, and so he can not only belt out notes that could easily shatter a piece of glass, but he also is very exaggerated with his facial expressions, costumes, make-up, etc. He’s like Prince or Cher, maybe even Britney Spears, in that the music is exciting, probably up-tempo and crazy, but you really only come to the show to see what he will do next. The reason Lambert has many fans is because he is an Idol first; he’s the first Idol who people are actually excited to see what he does next, and the first Idol who has pretty much destroyed arrangements (like that horrible rendition of “Ring of Fire” by Johnny Cash) and yet escaped with nothing but a few “I didn’t understand that performance” comments from Simon. He’s also the first openly gay contestant on American Idol. Lambert performs to shock an audience, and so people flock to him like he’s this bright and shiny object. I’m not sure where he will be in 10 years, of course, considering that someone who thrives on the exciting and the shock factor can only do it for a few years before it eventually gets old.
Kris Allen sings "She Works Hard for the Money" during Disco Week, and gets rave reviews.
Kris Allen, on the other hand, is someone who could have a lasting career. His voice sounds like a cross between Jason Mraz and Landon Pigg, both singer-songwriters known for their easy charisma and melodic music. Allen is the complete polar opposite to Lambert. He isn’t one for the spotlight, which doesn’t mean he doesn’t want to win the competition, it just means he has a different approach to his performances. Rather than deliver shocking performances and crazy vocal gymnastics, Allen’s best asset is the fact that he can arrange a song and make it his own – even a hit. His arrangement of the classic “Ain’t No Sunshine” was impeccable and original and made the song seem like it had only been released on the airwaves. His performances are very down-to-earth, and you can see that when he sings, he really does love making music. Allen is very earnest on stage and even though he has been consistently good during the course of the show, it was really only recently that he finally got the praise that he deserves.
The other two contestants are extremely predictable, which is why I am not going to be surprised if either one of them leaves in the weeks to come. Iraheta has a rock edge to her voice, but her arrangements are not original. The same can be said of Gokey, who has a nice tone to his voice and is a big belter, but who not only doesn’t arrange music personally, but has the personality of a rock. He also is the very American Idol-esque contestant on the show. He never really excites you when you are watching him. He just sings well. Iraheta has the same effect; not exciting, but she has a great voice.
I am rooting for Allen because he seems like the most genuine of the bunch. By genuine, I mean that he doesn’t seem to be in it for the fame, whereas Lambert seems to come off as such. I believe that Lambert is more suited for Broadway. He has the stage presence and the talent to be a big success on Broadway. I don’t think his voice is suited for making music. I’ve never had any desire to purchase any of his songs on iTunes, simply because I don’t feel the need to be shrieked at for 3 and a half minutes. I would go see Adam Lambert live, but I would go out and buy Allen’s album and see him live as well. I think Allen has the potential to have a long career in making music, and even Jamie Foxx has said he would want to make an album with Allen. I think that if Allen wins, he will be a first in American Idol history, because we’ve never had an Idol quite like him. The same is applicable to Adam Lambert. If Lambert wins, which is very likely (although I have by no means written off Allen), he will also make good of the American Idol title. I am just rooting for Allen because he is the underdog, and it’s about time that nice, talented guys who don’t live on hype finished first.